The Michigan AI search study · November 2026

Who AI recommends in Michigan, and why

We asked four AI assistants what Michigan business owners and their customers ask, then traced every business they named and every page they leaned on.

Edition 1ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, PerplexityNovember 2–17, 2026

48 answers

Twelve questions, each put to four AI assistants.

35 firms

Named across those answers. None in more than half.

5 of 7

“Best of” pages the assistants cited were written by a firm that ranked itself first.

10 of 12

Google searches from Lansing showed an AI answer above the results.

finding 01

No one owns the answer

Ask four assistants who to hire and you get four different lists. Across 48 answers, 35 firms were named. The two named most often turned up in 24 and 20 answers. Neither is based in Lansing, and their own pages are among the sources the assistants cite most.

Below them is a long tail: fifteen firms named three times or fewer. A place on these lists is still open.

How many of the 48 answers named each firm

24 of 48
20

Each bar is one firm, most-named first. Orange: the two named most, neither based in Lansing.

nimblefish check, November 15, 2026 · 4 assistants × 12 questions, web search on, signed out

Show the numbers
Answers naming the firmNumber of firms
241
201
151
131
101
81
72
63
52
47
35
27
13

finding 02

The lists come from businesses’ own pages

We followed the links. Among the pages the assistants cited most, firms’ own websites carried most of the weight: service pages that name the service and the place in plain words, and list articles the firms wrote themselves. Business directories came next.

Citations among the most-cited sources, by kind

Every source cited in four or more of the 48 answers.

Sources

  • A firm’s own website608
  • A business directory153
  • A link that hides the source121

nimblefish check, November 15, 2026

Show the numbers
Kind of sourceCitationsSources
A firm’s own website608
A business directory153
A link that hides the source (one assistant)121

An answer, drawn · names blurred

Sources the answer cited

  • An agency’s own page
  • An agency’s own page
  • A directory
  • A hidden link
An illustration of a typical answer: a numbered list of businesses, citing mostly the businesses’ own websites, then a directory, then a link that hides its source.

What Lansing Michigan Web agencies can help me get into AI answers?

Models like Perplexity and Google AI Overviews pull heavily from third-party sources (industry directories, local news, PR mentions, Reddit, review aggregators).

Gemini, November 15, 2026, word for word

finding 03

Most “best of” lists rank their author first

Seven ranking pages kept turning up in the answers. Five were written by a firm that put itself at number one; one says so on the page.

It’s how these lists get made, and the assistants read them all the same.

  • The best web design companies in Michigan

    Written by
    A web agency
    Ranked first
    The author

    Author ranks itself first

  • The best web design in Lansing

    Written by
    The same agency, which says so on the page
    Ranked first
    The author

    Author ranks itself first

  • The best SEO companies in Lansing

    Written by
    A development agency
    Ranked first
    The author

    Author ranks itself first

  • The best AI consulting firms in Michigan

    Written by
    An AI consulting firm
    Ranked first
    The author

    Author ranks itself first

  • The best AI consulting company in Michigan

    Written by
    Another AI consulting firm, answering about itself
    Ranked first
    The author

    Author ranks itself first

  • The best SEO agencies in Lansing

    Written by
    An editorial ranking site
    Ranked first
    An agency it scored

    Independent ranking

  • The best web designers in Lansing

    Written by
    A review site that businesses can’t pay
    Ranked first
    An agency it reviewed

    Independent ranking

  • 5 of 7

    ranked their own author first.

How to read a “best of” list

Three questions the seven pages answer, one way or the other.

  1. Who wrote it?
  2. Is the author at number one?
  3. Does it say how it scored?

nimblefish review of the pages the assistants cited, November 17, 2026 · publishers described by kind

finding 04

Google answers before it lists

On 10 of 12 searches from Lansing, Google put its own AI answer above the results, so a business can rank first and still sit below an answer that names someone else.

Monthly Google searches in Michigan, in one roofer’s field

The big searches don’t name a town.

  • roofers near me5,400
  • roofing3,600
  • metal roofing2,900
  • roofing contractor2,400
  • roof repair1,900
  • gutter installation1,300
  • replacement windows1,300

Google Ads data, November 2, 2026

Show the numbers
SearchMonthly in Michigan
roofers near me5400
roofing3600
metal roofing2900
roofing contractor2400
roof repair1900
gutter installation1300
replacement windows1300

Searches with an AI answer on top

12 searches from Lansing, and 168 in a roofer’s field.

10 of 12

65 of 168
roofing searches from three towns showed one too.

Google results, November 2 and 15, 2026

a word of warning

AI repeats your listings.

What the assistants said

  • “20 years of workmanship”
  • “10 to 20 years”

The real terms

  • 15 years of workmanship on one shingle line
  • 20 years of labor on other brands
Asked about the roofing contractor’s warranty, the assistants quoted its directory listings, and the listings were wrong.

finding 05

Known by name, missing by need

One example from outside our own field: a family roofing contractor in Eaton County, checked on November 2, before its new website. Every assistant knew it by name. Asked for a roofer without its name, they almost never brought it up, and Google’s map showed it in one town of twelve.

AI answers that named it

Asked about it by name

20 of 20

Asked for a roofer, no name given

4 of 60

4 assistants, November 2, 2026

Google’s map, searched from 12 nearby towns

First in its home town on all three searches. Not in the top 20 in the other eleven.

10 mi20 mi30 miHastings: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesHastingsMiddleville: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesMiddlevilleCaledonia: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesCaledoniaLowell: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesLowellGrand Ledge: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesGrand LedgeLake Odessa: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesLake OdessaHome town: first on all three map searchesHome: first, 3 of 3Charlotte: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesCharlotteLansing: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesLansingBattle Creek: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesBattle CreekMarshall: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesMarshallIonia: not in the top 20 on any of three map searchesIonia
  • First on Google’s map
  • Not in the top 20

Google Maps, November 2, 2026

Google reviews beside the four businesses holding Lansing’s map

The map leaders have 13 to 26 times as many.

  • Lansing map leader 1511
  • Lansing map leader 2469
  • Lansing map leader 3346
  • Lansing map leader 4255
  • The contractor20

Google Business Profiles, November 2, 2026

Show the numbers
BusinessGoogle reviews
Lansing map leader 1511
Lansing map leader 2469
Lansing map leader 3346
Lansing map leader 4255
The contractor20

the pattern

What the named businesses have in common

We read the pages behind the names. The businesses that kept coming up had pages that shared four things.

  1. A page named for the search

    The words a customer types, the service and the town, as the page’s title. Not one page that covers everything.

  2. One plain promise

    What you get, said once, in a sentence an assistant can repeat.

  3. A free or low-cost first step

    A check, an estimate, a snapshot. Something a person can say yes to today.

  4. A person or a number to quote

    A named owner, a review count, a year founded. Assistants pass along facts they can point to.

how we did it

Four sources, one picture

  • 01

    48 AI answers

    Twelve questions a Michigan owner or customer might ask, to four assistants, signed out, with web search on. November 15.

  • 02

    Every name counted

    Each business an answer named and each page it cited, tallied across all 48.

  • 03

    The cited pages, read

    Seventeen of the most-cited pages, read in full. November 17.

  • 04

    Google, from Lansing

    Page one for 12 searches, plus one roofing contractor’s searches, map and AI answers on November 2.

The study

Edition 1, November 2026

Answers change from day to day, so we count across many and ask the same questions each edition. Next edition: February 2027.

what it means for you

Five things worth doing

  1. Ask the assistants yourself

    Signed out, ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity for what you do in your town. Note who they name, and which pages they cite.

  2. Give each service and town its own page

    In plain words, with real local detail. One page for each search you want to win, never the same page with the town swapped.

  3. Get onto the lists they read

    The directories and review sites in your field. Most take a free profile. Keep your facts the same everywhere.

  4. Ask for reviews, steadily

    A few a month adds up, and it’s often the difference between being named and not.

  5. Offer a first step

    A free check or a fixed-price start gives an assistant something to recommend and a customer something to do.

Where does your business stand?

Tell us what you do and where. We’ll look at what AI assistants say when your customers ask.

Let’s talk

questions we hear often

A few questions we hear often.

How do AI assistants decide which Michigan businesses to recommend?

In our November 2026 check, they named businesses whose own pages say the service and the place in plain words, and businesses on the directories and "best of" pages they read. Reviews and plain facts, like an owner's name or a review count, help them describe a business with confidence.

Will my business show up in ChatGPT?

Ask it. Signed out, ask for what you do in your town and see who it names. If you're not there, look at the pages it cites: that's where it learned the names it gave you.

Do AI assistants all give the same answer?

No. The same question to four assistants gave four different lists, and the same assistant can answer differently from one day to the next. That's why we count across many answers instead of trusting one.

Does ranking on Google mean AI will recommend me?

Not on its own. Google showed an AI Overview on 10 of the 12 searches we ran from Lansing, and on at least one of them the businesses it cited weren't the one ranked first below it.

How often is this study updated?

Every few months, on the same questions, so the editions can be compared. The next edition is planned for February 2027.